Home

 










Succulent of the Month

 
 

Big Barrels

A man, his clothes in tatters, drags himself painfully across the sand when, to his amazement, he comes upon a peculiar looking, spiny, cylindrical object, perhaps equipped with a handy faucet. This classic cartoon image has undoubtedly introduced many people to the idea of the desert, and in particular, to that living drinking-fountain, the barrel cactus. His strength and spirits revived, our adventurer can now move forward and begin to build a golf-course or a casino, or some other symbol of the modern desert.

Just what are these so-called barrel cacti, a few curious types might ask? Are they really filled almost to bursting with pure, fresh water? Do they exist in a land other than that of the cartoon? Well, no, they’re not really filled with water, and yes, they most certainly do exist, in the arid landscapes of the American southwest, Baja California, and the Mexican mainland. Three and a half dozen cylindrical, distinctly ribbed plant species colloquially called barrel cacti belong to the rather similar looking, related genera Echinocactus and Ferocactus (each now including species once considered separate genera).

All these plants grow into a cylindrical shape, quite small in a few cases, squat and pulled low into the ground in some others, as much as eight or nine feet tall and three feet thick in the largest forms. Many species remain solitary, others offset sparsely from the base, and a relatively few species form large, many-headed clumps. In most cases the plants bear extremely thick, heavy spines, varying from short to very long according to species, and often with a curved central spine.

The dense woolly crowns of echinocacti set them apart from their Ferocactus cousins. In the United States, ferocacti generally grow in particularly arid sections of the Sonoran and Mojave deserts in southeast California, Arizona and parts of New Mexico. Our two native echinocacti live either in the higher elevations of the Mojave Desert, or well to the south, in far southern Texas, and the narrow extensions of the Chihuahuan Desert into Arizona and New Mexico. The two sunken genera complicate matters, as both of them come from Texas, where Homalocephala texensis is now Echinocactus texensis, and Hamatocactus hamatacanthus has turned into a Ferocactus, with the other members of its erstwhile genus scattered to the four winds, taxonomically speaking. In Mexico ferocacti and echinocacti grow over much of the country, though ferocacti have a somewhat more western distribution. Baja California, in particular, the home to a large number of interesting ferocacti, has no echinocacti at all.

The six species of Echinocactus have an odd, somewhat disrupted distribution. The largest species, E. platyacanthus, “the Giant Visnaga,” a tall growing, extremely massive cactus that ranges over much of northeast and central Mexico, can dominate a landscape because of its large size and impressive bulk. The plants (which have had several other names assigned to them, including Echinocactus ingens and Echinocactus grandis) often have a somewhat sway-backed, saddle-shaped apex, densely covered in white wool, where their yellow flowers emerge. Possibly the most common cactus in cultivation, the “Golden Barrel,” Echinocactus grusonii, admired for its symmetrical, round shape and bright yellow spines, in many ways seems like a somewhat smaller, less robust giant visnaga (or “bisnaga,” the generic term in Mexico for any barrel-type cactus). Curiously for such a frequently encountered plant in horticulture, its native habitat was quite small, the sloping sides of a series of canyons in Queretaro state, now almost completely submerged by a reservoir, and the species is almost extinct in the wild.

A third interesting species, Echinocactus horizonthalonius, comes from southern Texas and adjacent northeast Mexico, with a very limited extension into a bit of southern Arizona as well. Distinguished by its distinctly gray epidermis, it also produces a white woolly flowering top at its center. Its bright magenta flowers stand out dramatically against the arid white limestone hills where it often lives. E. texensis, sometime called the “Texas horse crippler” grows fairly low to the ground, where its thick, sharp, but fairly short spines could conceivably injure livestock (or anyone who stepped on one). Rarely reaching over a foot in diameter, or more than six inches in height, it grows in brush or grassland in much of east Texas, north to Oklahoma and south to northeast Mexico. In contrast to these generally solitary species, Echinocactus polycephalus (as its name implies) forms many-headed clumps of smallish barrels, densely covered with thick spines, either bright yellow or pink when young, aging to gray. E. polycephalus is a plant of the interior American deserts, growing along the Colorado River both west and east of the Grand Canyon, and stretching northwest to Death Valley and the high desert of Inyo County in California. An attractive plant with its compact size and colorful spines, E. polycephalus, unfortunately, is just about impossible to grow in cultivation, at best maintaining its form for a number of years after death until it finally collapses and dries up. Echinocactus horizonthalonius, although not as difficult as E. polycephalus, is also extremely hard to keep alive for more than a few years, at least in climates that share our wet, humid winters. Conversely, the other echinocacti grow readily in cultivation, without much fuss at all, and both the golden barrel and the giant visnaga will do well outdoors given good drainage. In containers, a standard, quick draining succulent soil mix, lots of sun, water once a week in the warm months, and perhaps every month or two in winter, will keep them thriving for years.

Almost all of the two and a half dozen species of Ferocactus also behave well in cultivation. Their bright flowers, in colors from yellow, through orange and red, to purple, poke out of their apices; unfortunately most must be large plants before they’ll flower. A number of them are familiar sights to anyone who’s traveled to Palm Springs or Tucson, including Ferocactus cylindraceus (the currently accepted name for the more familiar F. acanthodes) and Ferocactus wislizeni, tall growing, usually solitary barrels, with thick, somewhat curved spines that often glow bright red when young. Whether medium sized or large, most of the species endemic to Baja California and its neighboring islands share this general form as well. Ferocactus townsendianus, with a slightly glaucous body and dense spination, Ferocactus gracilis and Ferocactus emoryi all are typical attractive Baja species. So are Ferocactus cylindraceus spp. tortulispinus (formerly F. tortulispinus), with strange spiraling, twisting spines, and Ferocactus rectispinus (now considered Ferocactus emoryi ssp. rectispinus), with razor-sharp central spines up to ten inches long, each of them among the most fiercely armed of this generally fierce (“fero” means fierce) genus. Ferocactus pilosus (frequently called F. stainesii), from north-east and central Mexico and up to nine feet tall, with several subsidiary barrels growing from the main one, with deep green bodies densely covered with bright red spines up its entire length, may be the most spectacular of the species. Another plant from the islands off Baja, Ferocactus diguetii turns from a barrel into a column, over twelve feet tall and two feet thick.

Moving from big to small, coastal San Diego County still has a few Ferocactus viridescens, rarely more than a foot tall or in diameter, with a range extending down the Pacific coast into Baja. A little farther south down the Baja coast the quite limited habitat of Ferocactus fordii begins. A bit smaller than F. viridescens, this species will produce its pretty magenta flowers in a six or seven inch pot. Ferocactus latispinus, from central Mexico, will become somewhat larger, but it’s very easy to grow and with its thick, fairly short reddish spines, it makes a nice container specimen. With bright yellow spines and a distinctive blue-gray body, Ferocactus glaucescens stands out from the other species. Though it can reach over eighteen inches in diameter, it will nonetheless flower perfectly well in an eight inch pot. Finally, Ferocactus hamatacanthus (formerly Hamatocactus), also will flower in a medium sized container. It has unusually narrow spines for a Ferocactus that sometimes twist as well, and though it rarely becomes more than a solitary foot and a half tall cylinder in the extremely arid rocky outcrops that it favors in southern Texas, a couple of hundred miles south, in Coahuila, it sometimes grows in flat, almost barren dry lake beds where it produces five or six stemmed clusters a yard high.

Many ferocacti will grow outdoors if given very good drainage. Even our coldest temperatures rarely bother them, but the more arid-growing types will do better if given extra-good drainage and protection from the rain. The plants from northern Baja California and San Diego may grow through the winter (though our rainfall is so much higher than that of their habitats that their survival outdoors in wet or cold years can’t be guaranteed), and the plants on the whole can withstand a bit more winter water than most cacti. Still, once a month (or less) is a good bet for the cold time of year, once a week when it gets warm unless they’re obviously dormant. In the wild their ribs will expand and contract like an accordion according to the amount of liquid they hold, but this liquid exists in the form of gooey pulp, not at all accommodating to a faucet.

The Garden has a good collection of barrel cacti, with some nice old specimens a prominent feature of the New World Desert area, and more variety inside the Arid House. We generally have some to sell from time to time.

-Fred Dortort


Fred Dortort has grown cacti and succulent plants for thirty years. He's studied and observed plants in Baja California, mainland Mexico, South Africa, Namibia and the American southwest. He's lectured widely on succulent plants, has taught classes at the Botanical Garden, and written numerous articles for the Cactus and Succulent Journal, as well as publications such as Pacific Horticulture and Garden.

Fred is a Garden Volunteer. We appreciate his time and knowledge, working with the succulent and cactus collection (Arid House) and helping with propagation for our Plant Sales.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]